Lakenheath Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lakenheath bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore housing near Lakenheath courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Koran Burning

who's talking here?

ShizzleShizzleDizzleDizzle 3
WitnessProtectionProgram 1
Matt 1
here in UK 4
Jaymi 1
Rolf 1
O.o 3
BenedettaMamma 4
invaderzim 1
Um Really? 3
KillerKlowns31 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

BenedettaMamma --- 16 years ago -

Personally I think that while one has the constitutional to do it doesn't mean they SHOULD do it.

I have a constitutional right to walk up to some random stranger and say (s)he is an ugly piece of trash and I hope their house burns down. That doesn't mean I SHOULD. And it doesn't mean that people shouldn't and wouldn't be "up in arms" about my actions- especially if it means something to them personally.

I do not follow the Koran, nor am I a devout Christian or any one faith for that matter... but I respect all religions and their beliefs. Burning a holy relic is just blatant disrespect, and while it may not seem like much to you, to some it is everything.

In fact I know there would be a great many people who would care if someone burned a pile of bibles and for you to think otherwise is pretty ridiculous.

Just as if someone were to burn something that held great significance to you, merely because they disagreed with you.

I don't think that by being so antagonistic speaks very highly of his teachings or his church. I feel bad for him. I would like to think that my pastor would want to promote peace and tolerance... Not destruction and disrespect...

But that's just me... 

Um Really? --- 16 years ago -

I personally think its whatever. Am I scared for the troops? Yes I am. We have lost too many people as it is. You know the American forces will be the ones to pay for his Koran burning.

But I do understand where the pastor is coming from. It is okay for them to burn down churches and kill people based on them not being Muslim. I don't think thats right.
I don't think its right that they can burn American flags and kill all kinds of people because they think we are wrong in what we believe or don't believe.
Just because we don't believe what they do doesn't mean we should be killed.
Do 2 wrongs make a right, no they really don't.

Then again look at that baptist church who protest at troops funerals. No matter what anyone does no one will ever be happy. We could have World Peace and I'm sure somebody somewhere wouldn't be happy. 

BenedettaMamma --- 16 years ago -

Those Westboro Baptist bastards are a prime example of "just cause you can doesn't mean you should".

I really really despise those people.

God bless the Patriot Guard Riders! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriot_Guard_Riders 

Um Really? --- 16 years ago -

I 110% agree with you Dana! 

O.o (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

It is okay for them to burn down churches and kill people based on them not being Muslim. I don't think thats right.
I don't think its right that they can burn American flags and kill all kinds of people because they think we are wrong in what we believe or don't believe.
Just because we don't believe what they do doesn't mean we should be killed.



Who is "we" and who is "them?" Sorry, but I've taken too many classes in war making and peace making to be ok with arbitrarily using that type of vocab, even if I agree with the general meaning behind what was said.

In case you're not aware, that type of jargon is what made it all too easy for the Nazi's to carry out their "cleansing", the US to get support for Japanese concentration camps and build up the "red threat," and the Hutus to kill over 800,000 tutsis in a week. The "us" vs "them" divide and conquer strategy is a horribly effective tactic for separating humans from other humans based on any difference that is convenient. Please don't fall prey to it.

I didn't know about the Patriot Guard Riders, but what a great idea and an excellent way of thinking outside the violence box. 

Jaymi --- 16 years ago -

I'm absolutely disgusted by the Qur'an burning and even more disgusted by the media for giving this coverage.

Nothing good will come of this. This will only create more hate, more fear and more animosity between two religions that pretty much worship the same freaking god. (Abrahamic religions, google it.) 

O.o (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

You mean the islamic center (which will have a culinary school among other things) that's like 5 blocks away? And that is being built because the old one (that has been there since before even the twin towers were built) couldn't renew its lease?

Seriously, why do people just eat up the hype and buy in to fear and anger before lifting a finger for understanding? It's much more rewarding and doesn't make you look like a uneducated idiot. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Couldn't have said it better O.o!

Its not a certain religion that does these things, its the extremists who have twisted their beliefs to fit their hatred and hide behind their "faith".

And yes, I think a lot of people would freak out if a muslim church decided to burn bibles. Especially if they did so on 9/11 like this "church" is planning on doing. Doing so on this day is not just a symbol of what religion they believe was the cause of that day, but the religion and the people in general who share the same faith. 

ShizzleShizzleDizzleDizzle (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Personally I don't see what the big deal is.....it is happening in America where he is protected by the constitution....right to protest, and yes this can be considered peaceful.

Telling someone they are ugly and that you hope their house burns down is considered "fighting words" and is NOT protected by the constitution....it is implying you have serious ill intent.

I fully believe Americans should exercise their rights to the fullest! If not then why have them and more importantly why fight and die for them?!

That IS the true beauty of the US Constitution.....we don't have to like what the other guy is doing but if it is within his rights then why whine & complain and get all in depth about it?

It's like those Westboro Baptist losers.....I can't stand what they spew and the great lengths they will go to spread there vile message but they are within their rights. I think this guy (and his small church) burning Korans is NOTHING compared to Westboro Baptist and many other true extremists out there. This guy is merely peacefully protesting.....and as far as I know it is going to happen on the church's private property right? My 2 cents......I knows hows yous kids like my opinion, extra schloppy! 

here in UK --- 16 years ago -

To chime in on the "islamic center" being built.. There wouldnt be as much hype/issue if Taliban money wasnt funding it. Just a FYI, most of the contributers to this "center" also contribute to the Taliban. See an issue yet? Then to have Pelosi wanting to investigate 9/11 familes that are fighting this but not investigate the muslim side of it come on. See an issue?

BTW, I say burn it.. In the end its not hurting anyone, there already out to kill us. All americans are targets, they already burn our flag daily, the media is just causeing hype to take the headlines away from the Gulf Oil issue, Iran Nuclear Issue, Health care bill, etc.. Things that are more improtant, but being covered up. I mean really, its a church with 50 followers, and this much hype... 

Matt --- 16 years ago -

BTW, I say burn it.. In the end its not hurting anyone, there already out to kill us. All americans are targets, they already burn our flag daily,

So what your saying is ALL Muslims who read the Koran are out to kill us and burn the flag daily? 

here in UK --- 16 years ago -

Nope, but not all people are out to burn the koran either.. So why get bent about it..

I do disagree with the mosque being built there, especially since there plane is to paint the front of it green, which if you know anything about there history thats a mark of victory. Its being funded by Terrorist. I could go on but people would just argue, and no point in argueing with facts.

Its a holy war, we stuck our nose into it... Now we have to deal with it.. 

BenedettaMamma --- 16 years ago -

@James Telling someone they are ugly and that you hope their house burns down is considered "fighting words" and is NOT protected by the constitution....it is implying you have serious ill intent.

I beg to differ... "Fighting words" would be if I used a derogatory term or racial slur for one, and hoping that their house burns down is far different from saying "I am going to burn your house down".

Just as those Westboro Baptist a-holes can say "Pray For More Dead Soldiers" etc. You can wish ill will on someone but can not pose a specific threat. If you said you hope their house burns down while holding a flame thrower aimed at their house... Bingo. Otherwise, Constitutionally sound, my friend. 

O.o (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

burning Korans is NOTHING compared to Westboro Baptist

That's your opinion, isn't it? To some burning the Quran is everything. And no it's NOT a peaceful protest. It is intentionally meant to hurt people. There are American muslims, white muslims, black muslims, etc... This is meant to hurt all of them. But who will retaliate? Of course more extremists. So what is the purpose of this book burning other than to incite more violence from those who are already violent and to hurt those who have no part in it.

Just a FYI, most of the contributers to this "center" also contribute to the Taliban.

Sources?

It's funny that people can say "look! illegal immigrants!" and suddenly a mexican american no longer looks like a fellow man. They can say "look! a liberal!" and suddenly your neighbor looks like a communist. They can say "look! a terrorist!" and suddenly any dark skinned guy with a beard is a threat.

Rise above the hype. Don't become swayed by intolerance and exclusion. Be better than that. 

here in UK --- 16 years ago -

@ O.o... Research the groups that are giving money to the mosque and there you will see for yourself. Ill let you educate yourself. By doing alittle research you'll see alot that the "news" doesnt like to identify. 

here in UK --- 16 years ago -

Guess this is a dead issue now since the church was pressured by the government to cancel the event...

But yet, you dont see the government stepping in when people burn our flag, protest at military funerals, etc etc etc...

Awell.... 

ShizzleShizzleDizzleDizzle (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fighting_words

Dana, this is the definition of "Fighting Words". It is NOT protected under the constitution.....this is the one that most Americans break all the time without realizing it. It is NOT protected under "Free Speech". I went to school for this! 

ShizzleShizzleDizzleDizzle (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Bummer, their not going to do it?! I don't have anything against Islam in the slightest but I did agree that this church had the right to do this if they wanted to (and it was within the law....which it WAS).

Peaceful protest....in other words THEY weren't stringing someones dead charred body up from a bridge while unloading twenty 30 rounds 7.62mm clips in the air screaming "lalalalalalala ALLAH!".

What is more peaceful? Burning a book in a country where we are free to do it, on private property no less! Or Parading around a war torn village dragging the dead bodies of American Troops while everyone dances in the streets?

I'm former US Army.....NEVER and I DO MEAN NEVER forget our US Rangers that died in Bosnia. Nor should we forget the Blackwater personnel that died in the Middle East, they had their bodies desecrated to the fullest! The SHAME.

Do you see the difference between peaceful protest yet? 

BenedettaMamma --- 16 years ago -

incite hatred or violence from their target

i.e. if I was to say "Hey Joe, go burn Sally's house down" and he does. I am inciting hatred or violence. Same as if I go online and post a blog that says YOU ALL MUST GO FORTH AND DESTROY JOE'S LIFE! BURN HIS HOUSE! BEAT HIM UP! STEAL HIS SHOES! DO MY BIDDING!

AND if you read the "post Chaplinsky" section it states there: "holding that mere offensiveness does not qualify as 'fighting words'"

By saying someone is ugly, and trash I am not slandering them (saying something I KNOW to be untrue but say as a means to get a person fired, in trouble with the law etc.) so I am within my constitutional rights.

Similarly, by saying I hope something bad happens to them, whether I am specific or not is NOT the same as THREATENING them with that specific action! So, just as the KKK can publicly wish ill upon the blacks and jews etc., and the W. Baptists and publicly wish ill upon the soldiers, gays etc., it is all constitutional, so long as neither publicly and specifically incite people to go and act upon those wishes of ill will.

The KKK can say all day long what they would like to happen, but until they say "Grab your bats and torches and lets go kick some a$$!" and because of that a group of people get bloodied up THAT is inciting violence!

My husband also went to school for this and he and I have many long talks lately regarding the constitution, mosque, rights, politics etc. I know what I'm talking about, darlin'. 

Rolf --- 16 years ago -

So Brian, how did you know that this whole koran burning issue was to try and stop a mosque being built at ground zero ?
No mention of this was made anywhere in the media until the end..?
Do you know the pastor in FL ? 

Um Really? --- 16 years ago -

Who is "we" and who is "them?"

We as in The American people.
Them as in Muslim extremists.

Next time I'll be more specific. Its been awhile since Ive been apart of any forum. 

KillerKlowns31 --- 16 years ago -

I don't see what all the fuss is about


0 

invaderzim --- 16 years ago -

ha ha ha. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lakenheath Underground